Darwin sought to not only produce a new scientific truth, but also to put an end to polygenism, the current scientific discourse on human origins that gave tacit and at times explicit support for slavery: ‘... when the principle of evolution is generally accepted, as it surely will be before long, the dispute between the monogenists and polygenists will die a silent and unobserved death.’ (Charles Darwin, Descent of Man, p. 235)

Saturday, June 25, 2011

The New York Times Article and Editorial. Comment I on "Morton vs Gould"


In the study of life, all knowledge is provisional. Just as it is the establishment of laws fundamental to the sciences, so too is skepticism equally important to the sciences --- and those which aspire to be included in the sciences--- and the long struggle to free scientific rationality from dogma and ideology itself demonstrates that conclusions are subject to change and reinterpretation. This is in fact what the authors want to do with the essay under review: to alter our interpretation. To the extent that they succeed is in fact this same aspect of scientific rationality that both makes their work open to use in support of dogma and ideology, and makes it persuasive as well. Similarly, if we take the example of historical sociology, we find our understanding of the the past is provisional and interpretations change as well as the disciplining and division of labor in society change over time.

For example, would today often read a text on the urban poor like that of Morton’s contemporary, Henry Mayhew, who for his time would be considered a reformist journalist and advocate for the poor:

“As animals have their habit, so there is a large class of mankind which single cleverness is that of representing themselves as justly and naturally dependent on the assistance of others, who look paupers from their birth, who seek givers and forsake those who have given as naturally as a tree sends its roots into new soil and deserts the exhausted. It is the office of reason --- reason improved by experience --- to teach us not to waste our own interest and our resources on beings that will be content to live on our bounty, and will never return a moral profit to our charitable industry. The great opportunities or the mighty powers that heaven may have given us, it never meant to be lavished on mere human animals who eat, drink, and sleep, and whose only instinct is to find out a new caterer when the old one is exhausted.” (from The London Labour and the London Poor. New York: Penguin Classics, 1985:509.)
But of course, one must acknowledge that neither the search for laws nor radical skepticism have prevented many from asserting that their view of history is the one true history. Sextus Empiricus’ radical skepticism was geared towards preventing the acceptance of dogma as fact.

The PLoS Biology essay on Stephen Jay Gould and Samuel George Morton [Lewis JE, DeGusta D, Meyer MR, Monge JM, Mann AE, et al. (2011) The Mismeasure of Science: Stephen Jay Gould versus Samuel George Morton on Skulls and Bias. PLoS Biol 9(6): e1001071. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001071 ]

is to be understood from a number of perspectives, and this certainly leaves it open to narrow ideological readings. The range of these readings express the various commitments of its many readers and commentators.

The first place to turn is the article in the New York Times that announced the Lewis, DeGusta article.
“Scientists Measure the Accuracy of a Racism Claim”  by Nicholas Wade

The New York Times Article

The headline of the article, which is not the responsibility of the Wade, is of course somewhat sensational. Gould and Lewis, DeGusta, et al. agree that Morton held views that today would be considered racists, though racialist is a better term. Lewis, DeGusta et al. are not attempting to dispute Morton’s racialism, but whether that scientific ideology caused Morton to inaccurately report the measurements of the crania in his collection. This is a very narrow question, which Gould believed to be current based upon his examination of Morton’s results, but that the authors of the new article believe to be not the case.

Much of the the Wade/NYTimes article is a largely accurate characterization and summary of Lewis, DeGusta, et al., except for a sentence that the new study “does little to burnish Dr. Gould’s reputation as a scholar.” In fact, Gould reputation as a scholar does not and never did rest on his essay and later chapter on Morton’s craniological studies. Much like his hero, Charles Darwin, Gould’s work as a naturalist was never divorced from his other work. Just as Darwin’s work was partly motivated by his anti-slavery convictions, so too was Gould compelled to use science as a basis for an intervention into the large political questions of his day. Gould was also a scientist who intervened into the history of science and its popular understanding, particularly in the arena of the public understanding and misunderstanding of Darwin’s work. The work The Mismeasure of Man falls into this group of popular political writings. It is a book about biological determinism and the then current political/popular debates over race as an explanation for intelligence. And popularizing and popularity are always something that one’s detractors will point towards as a sign of lack of scientific integrity. It is useful to compare Mismeasure with his more academic Ontegeny and Phylogeny (1978), wherein Morton is not mentioned, and his Structure of Evolutionary Thought, where again Morton does not appear. This can not help be raise a question concerning the centrality of the chapter on Morton to Gould’s body of work. We will save such notices and discussions until a later posting in this series.

Wade’s summary of Lewis, DeGusta, et al.:

A. “Morton did not manipulate his data to support his preconceptions.”

B. The study is based on remeasuring half of the human crania in Morton’s collection (his collection contained examples of the crania of many non-human species as well).

C. Gould accuses Morton of omitting “subgroups to manipulate a groups overall score.... Gould himself also omitted subgroups in his own analysis and made various errors in his calculations. When these are corrected, the differences between the racial categories recognized by Morton are as he assigned them.” No mention is made in the Wade article of the conclusions that Morton drew from these results, i.e., that race could ve used to classify humans into fixed categories that result from different species or “Primordial organic form[s]” or each from a separate “primitive variety.” [Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia for September and October, 1849. See also Morton’s description of race from his Catalogue of Skulls of Man and Inferior Animals in the Collection of Samuel George Morton [http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2011/06/gould-versus-morton-debate-text-i.html ]

To be sure, Lewis, DeGusta, et all. are clear that:

“In reevaluating Morton and Gould, we do not dispute that racist views were unfortunately common in 19th-century science [PLoS FN6] or that bias has inappropriately influenced research in some cases [PLoS FN16]. Furthermore, studies have demonstrated that modern human variation is generally continuous, rather than discrete or “racial,” and that most variation in modern humans is within, rather than between, populations [PLoS FN11],[PLoS FN17]. In particular, cranial capacity variation in human populations appears to be largely a function of climate, so, for example, the full range of average capacities is seen in Native American groups, as they historically occupied the full range of latitudes [PLoS FN18]. It is thus with substantial reluctance that we use various racial labels, but it is impossible to discuss Morton and Gould's work without using the terms they employed (Lewis, DeGusta, et al., 2011:2)

Regarding the final statement it is no doubt true that the collection of data and the analysis and interpretation of that data are intimately connected. So much so that the “racial labels” can not be avoided, though it is good to point out that Gould and Morton did not attach the same meaning and degree of fixity to those labels. The dispute then is over the accuracy of Morton’s measurements and the fairness of Gould characterizations that he based on his own analysis. The errors in Gould’s analysis are not shown in the article to be the result of conscious error or deliberate manipulation. Gould also did not accuse Morton of conscious error or deliberate manipulation.

D. “‘Ironically, Gould’s own analysis of Morton is likely the stronger example of a bias influencing results.’” A stronger example, but not a demonstration that bias does not influence scientific work, but rather an affirmation that scientific work can be biased, which might be he most ironic aspect of the so-called debate.

The author’s paragraph on Morton’s interpretation of his data was not mentioned in the Times article. No doubt, this was done in order to set up the inevitable journalistic trope of “two sides to every story.” We are presented with an ambiguous statement by Lewis regarding Gould’s integrity, but as it is obviously out of context, it is simply ambiguous.

The real contest is prefaced by the mention of an article by John S. Michael, who as an undergraduate at the University of Pennsylvania “Concluded that Morton’s results were ‘reasonably accurate’ with no clear sign of manipulation.” The reason this is mentioned is because it will be referred to in the concluding ‘exchange” between Philip Kitcher and Ralph L Holloway, the former having defended Gould in the matter of the Mitchel article, with the later being one of the authors of the study. The dispute is presented as being about the appropriateness of “prefer[ring] the measurements of an undergraduate to those of a professional paleontologist.” But as we know and as Gould himself states in the Mismeasure of Man and Lewis, DeGusta, et al. attest as well, Gould did not do any measurements of the skulls himself.

The mention of Michael’s work leads to the last question on “the new finding’s bearing on Dr. Gould’s reputation. Kitcher gives the first response: “Steve does not come off as a rogue but as someone who makes mistakes.”

The more biting, and volatile sentiment is left for last, from the co-author Ralph L Holloway
“an expert on human evolution at Columbia and a co-author of the new study, was less willing to give Dr. Gould benefit of the doubt. 'I just didn’t trust Gould,' he said. 'I had the feeling that his ideological stance was supreme. When the 1996 version of ‘The Mismeasure of Man’ came and he never even bothered to mention Michael’s study, I just felt he was a charlatan.'”
Regarding the rather extreme accusation that Gould was a charlatan, only time will tell but there seems to be little evidence for such a claim. Certainly, the idea that Gould was deliberately fraudulent in his work would demand a good deal more proof than a few computation errors, no matter what implications he took from the results of those errors. Certainly the same could be said for Morton. Or is it that Gould’s errors were errors of computation, while Morton’s were errors of interpretation?



Gould seems to force the chapter on Morton into a work about biological determinism. It and the other early chapters of Mismeasure are presented as the historical backdrop for the then current debate on intelligence testing and social welfare policy. The focus of the book is not Gould’s exposure of any errors by Morton. Morton simply provides one example of many  naturalists who subscribed to polygenism and who believed that race explained difference.  Perhaps this is the basis for the erroneous assertion that Gould’s discussion of Morton is a central aspect of the Mismeasure of Man. It was not and the value of Gould's work does not rise and fall on is attempt to replicate Morton's analysis.  Gould did his analysis of Morton’s data intermittently over the course of several weeks.  He really seems to have spent very little time on it.  And perhaps most importantly, Gould relied for the most part on Stanton’s wonderful book The Leopard’s Spots for his discussion of Morton and polygenism. Likewise, Lewis, DeGusta, et al. also use Stanton’s book as their authority, though Stanton's work would not provide them much support in terms his critique of Morton's interpretations of his measurements and his polygenism.

Gould’s larger error was not in seeing science as embedded in society, nor in missing his own computational errors, but in his attempt to establish a continuity between phrenology, Morton’s craniology, Lombroso’s criminal anthropology, and later theories of intelligence and the ranking of groups by intelligence testing. All of these he saw as examples of a biological determinism that could be found in both scientific research and in the social policies that arose from that scientific data. However, there are significant differences between these “wretched knowledges” (Neugebauer) and scientific ideologies (Canguilhem). Though Morton and the phrenologist Combes were good friends, Morton moved significantly away from phrenology by examining the capacity of the crania rather than its external characteristics. Morton’s work was undertaken before the transition from Natural History to Biology, and so Morton’s determinism is not really biological as it is based on the fixity of species. Lombroso’s theory of degeneration is a product of the post-Darwinian period and not directly derived from Buffon, for example, and owed little to Morton. Lombroso’s socialism also has little resemblance to Gould’s. 
 
Measurement does provide some continuity, but one would expect measurement of some kind in any rational investigation. In each era, measurements are being taken, but of different things and for different reasons. In terms of the study of human variation, Gould's discussion does not go into detail about the social context as much as he more pursues the history of ideas, a pursuit that was common when Mismeasure of Man was published some thirty years ago.

As for responding to critics, Gould states in the revised 2nd edition that in terms of negative reviews:

“I firmly believe in not answering negative reviews, for nothing can so disorient an attacker as silence. But this was a bit too much [re: a negative review in The Public Interest that the first edition was, as he in part summarized as “politically motivated crap”], so I canvassed among friends. Both Noam Chomsky and Salvador Luria, great scholar and humanists, said essentially the same thing: never reply unless your attacker has floated a demonstrably false argument, which, if unanswered, might develop a ‘life of its own.’” (Mismeasure, 2nd edition, p.45).

On his own possible biases, Gould wrote that:
“We must identify preferences in order to constrain their influence on our work, but we do not go astray when we use such preferences to decide what subjects we wish to pursue. Life is short, and potential studies infinite. We have a much better chance of accomplishing something significant when we follow our passionate interests and work in areas of deepest personal meaning. Of course such a strategy increases dangers of prejudice, but the gain in dedication can overbalance any such worry, especially if we remain equally committed to the overarching general goal of fairness, and fiercely committed to constant vigilance and scrutiny of our personal biases” (Mismeasure, 2nd, p.37).
In the editorial the next day, the Times concluded that:
“The team expressed admiration for Dr. Gould’s body of work in staunch opposition to racism, but, in this case, it accused him of various errors and manipulations that supported his own hypothesis. “Ironically, Gould’s own analysis of Morton is likely the stronger example of a bias influencing results,” the team said. We wish Dr. Gould were here to defend himself. Right now it looks as though he proved his point, just not as he intended.”
In the caption for the photo accompanying the article above Wade's, neuro-scientist Nora D. Volkow, the Director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse is quoted as saying “Science and politics are intertwined.”

_________________

Canguilhem, Georges.  1988.  Ideology and Rationality in the History of the Life Sciences.  Cambridge: MIT Press.

Gould, Stephen Jay. The Mismeasure of Man, 2nd Revised and expanded edition. 1996 [first edition 1981].

Lewis JE, DeGusta D, Meyer MR, Monge JM, Mann AE, et al. (2011) The Mismeasure of Science: Stephen Jay Gould versus Samuel George Morton on Skulls and Bias. PLoS Biol 9(6): e1001071. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001071 ]
http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pbio.1001071

Mayhew, Henry. The London Labour and the London Poor. New York: Penguin Classics, 1985:509.

New York Times. “Bias and the Beholder.” Wednesday, June 15, 2011.
 https://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/15/opinion/15wed4.html

New York Times. Profiles in Science: Nora D. Volkow, A General in the Drug War. New York Times, Tuesday, June 14, 2011, D1-D4.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/14/science/14volkow.html?scp=2&sq=nora%20volkow&st=cse

Neugebauer, Otto.  1983.  Astronomy and History: Selected Essays.  New York: Springer-Verlag.

Stanton W (1960) The Leopard's Spots. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Wade, Nichlas. “Scientists Measure the Accuracy of a Racism Claim” New York Times, Tuesday, June 14, 2011. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/14/science/14skull.html?_r=1&src=me

The Geography of Human Variety according to Blumenbach

Thursday, June 16, 2011

The "Gould versus Morton" Debate -- Text II: Some Passages from the MisMeasure of Man, 2nd edition on Morton, the Value and relation of Science to Society, Agassiz, and John Collins


This is a set of passages from Stephan Jay Gould's The Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition.  New York: W. W. Norton, 1996.  It is t is a companion post to the text from Samuel G. Morton.


On The Relations of Science and Society
“Yet the history of many scientific subjects is virtually free from such constraints of fact for two major reasons. First, some topics are invested with enormous social importance but blessed with very little reliable information. When the ratio of data to social impact is so low, a history of scientific attitudes may be little more than an oblique record of social change. The history of scientific views on race, for example, serves as a mirror of social movements (Provine, 1973). This mirror reflects in good times and bad, in periods of belief in equality and in eras of rampant racism. The death knell of the old eugenics in America was sounded more by Hitler’s particular use of once-favored arguments for sterilization and racial purification than by advances in genetic knowledge.
Second, many questions are formulated by scientists in such a restricted way that any legitimate answer can only validate a social preference. Much of the debate on racial differences in mental worth, for example, proceed upon the assumption that intelligence is a thing in the head. Until this notion was swept aside, no amount of data could dislodge a strong Western tradition of ordering related items into a progressive chain of being.
Science cannot escape its curious dialectic. Embedded in surrounding culture, it can, nonetheless, be a powerful agent for questioning and even overturning the assumptions that nurture it. Science can provide information to reduce the ration of data to social importance. Scientists can struggle to identify the cultural assumptions of their trade and to ask how answers might be formulated under different assertions. Scientists can propose creative theories that force startled colleagues to confront unquestioned procedures. But science’s potential as an instrument for identifying the cultural constraints upon it cannot be fully realized until scientists give up the twin myths of objectivity and inexorable march toward truth. One must, indeed, locate the beam in one’s own eye before interpreting correctly the pervasive motes in everybody else’s. The beams can then become facilitators, rather than impediments.”
Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition, 54-55.

Gould on Agassiz and Morton:
“Agassiz speculated freely and at length, but he amassed no data to support his polygenic theory. Morton, a Philadelphia patrician with two medical degrees --- one from fashionable Edinburgh --- provided the ‘facts’ that won worldwide respect for the ‘American School’ of polygeny.... Yet Morton gathered skulls neither for the dilettante’s motive of abstract interest nor the taxonomist’s zeal for complete representation. He had a hypothesis to test: that ranking of races could be established objectively by physical characteristics of the brain, particularly by its size.
Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition, p. 83.

Morton’s work and its later use:
“Morton published three major works on the sizes of human skulls --- his lavish, beautifully illustrated volume on American Indians, the Crania Americana of 1839; his studies of skulls from the Egyptian tombs, the Crania Egyptiaca of 1844; and the epitome of his collection in 1849. Each contained a table, summarizing his results on average skull volumes arranged by race.... [The tables] represent the major contribution of American polygeny to debates about racial ranking. They outlived the theory of separate creations and were reprinted during the nineteenth century as irrefutable, ‘hard’ data on the mental worth of human races.”
Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition, p. 85.

Gould’s brief against Morton’s work:
During the summer of 1977 I spent several weeks reanalyzing Morton’s data. (Morton, the self-styled objectivist, published all his raw information. We can infer with little doubt how he moved from raw measurements to summary tables.) In short, and to put it bluntly, Morton’s summaries are a patchwork of fudging and finagling in the clear interest of controlling a priori convictions. Yet--- and this is the most intriguing aspect of the case --- I find no evidence of conscious fraud; indeed, had Morton been a conscious fudger, he would not have published his data so openly.
Conscious fraud is probably rare in science. It is also not very interesting, for it tells us nothing about the nature of scientific activity. Liars, if discovered, are excommunicated; scientists declare that their profession has properly policed itself, and they return to work, mythology unimpaired, and objectively vindicated. The prevalence of Unconscious finagling, on the other hand, suggests a general conclusion about the context of science. For if scientists can be honestly self-deluded to Morton’s extent, then prior prejudice may be found anywhere, even in the basic of measuring bones and toting sums.
Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition, p. 86.

Gould on the quality of the illustrations in Morton’s work:
“The lithographs of this and the next figure were done by John Collins, a great scientific artist unfortunately unrecognized today.”  
Mismeasure of Man, 2nd edition, p. 90.

The "Gould versus Morton" Debate -- Text I: Samuel George Morton’s Description of his Collection of Crania



As I go over the materials for a post about the recent article PLoS Biology article "The Mismeasure of Science: Stephen Jay Gould versus Samuel George Morton on Skulls and Bias." by Lewis, DeGusta, et al., I thought it might be a good idea to go ahead and post some relevant extracts from Morton and Gould.

Below is Morton's description of his collection, presented at the Academy of Natural Sciences and included as the Introduction to Catalogue of Skulls of Man and Inferior Animals in the Collection of Samuel George Morton, third edition. Philadelphia: Merrihew & Thompson, 1849, p. i-x.

This is the text in full with accompanying tables. Click on the images to see the table in full size.


INTRODUCTION

The primary motive in making the following collection has been to compare the characters of the cranium in different races of men, and these again with the skulls of the interior animals, not only in reference to their exterior form, but also to internal capacity as indicative of the size of the brain.”

Besides these strictly Ethnographic objects, some others of a different and subordinate kind have been had in view; such as pathological conditions of the skull from diseases and from wounds; remarkable developments illustrative of the principles of Phrenology, and preternatural growths of every description.

The Indian crania contained in this series have received my especial attention, both in respect to their number and authenticity, for they have been collected with great care by gentlemen whose names are associated with them. In every instance where a doubt is entertained as to the tribe or nation to which the skull belonged, it is expressed by a mark of interrogation; and where no clue exists for such information, the deficiency is noted accordingly. I have sometimes had the skulls of both Europeans and Africans sent to me by mistake for those of Indians: that these should occasionally be mingled in the same cemeteries is readily understood; but a practised eye can separate them without difficulty.

Large as this collection already is, a glance at the Ethnological Table will show that it is very deficient in some divisions of the human family. For example, it contains no skulls of the Eskimaux, Fuegians, Californians or Brazilians. The distorted heads of the Oregon tribes are also but partially represented, while the long-headed people of the Lake of Titicaca, in Bolivia, are altogether wanting. Skulls also of the great divisions of the Caucasian and Mongolian tribes of Northern Asia and China, are among the especial desiderata of this collection.

The following analysis exhibits an Ethnographic view of the materials embraced in the entire series.

The letters F. A. express the facial angle, and I. C. refer to the internal capacity of the cranium as obtained by the process invented by my friend Mr. J. S. Phillips, and described in my Crania Americana, p. 253, merely substituting leaden shot, one-eighth of an inch in diameter, in place of the white mustard-seed originally used. I thus obtain the absolute capacity of the cranium, or bulk of the brain, in cubic inches; and the results are annexed in all those instances in which I have had leisure to put this revised mode of measurement in practice. I have restricted it, at least for the purpose of my inferential conclusions, to the crania of persons of sixteen years of age and upwards, at which period the brain is believed to possess the adult size. Under this age, the capacity-measurement has only been resorted to for the purpose of collateral comparison.

All the measurements in this Catalogue, both of the facial angle and internal capacity, have been made with my own hands. I at one time employed a person to aid me in these elaborate and fatiguing details; but having detected some errors in his measurements, I have been at the pains to revise all that part of the series that had not been previously measured by myself. I can now, therefore, vouch for the accuracy of these multitudinous data, which I cannot but regard as a novel and important contribution to Ethnological science.

It is necessary to add, that the measurements originally published in the Crania Americana were made with seeds, which will explain the discrepancy between the numbers observable in that work and this catalogue. The measurements of the Crania Egyptiaca having been originally made with shot, require no revision: nor can I avoid expressing my satisfaction at the singular accuracy of this method, since a skull of an hundred cubic inches, if measured any number of times with reasonable care, will not vary a single cubic inch.


I am now engaged in a memoir which will embrace the detailed conclusions that result from these data; and meanwhile I submit the following tabular view of the prominent facts.

In this table the measurements of children, idiots and mixed races are omitted, excepting only in the instance of the Fellahs of Egypt, who, however, are a blended stock of two Caucasian nations,—the true Egyptian and the intrusive Arab, in which the characteristics of the former greatly predominate.


“No mean has been taken of the Caucasian race* collectively. Because of the very great preponderance of Hindu, Egyptian and Fellah skulls over those of the Germanic, Pelasgic and Celtic families. Nor could any just collective comparison be instituted between the Caucasian and Negro groups in such a table, unless the small-brained people of the latter division (Hottentots, Bushmen and Australians) were proportionate in number to the Hindoos, Egyptians and Fellahs of the other group. Such a computation, were it practicable, would probably reduce the Caucasian average to about 87 cubic inches, and the Negro to 78 at most, perhaps even to 75, and thus confirmatively establish the difference of at least nine cubic inches between the mean of the two races.*[**]


*“It is necessary to explain what is here meant by the word race. Further researches into Ethnographic affinities will probably demonstrate that what are now termed the five races of men, would be more appropriately called groups; that each of these groups is again divisible into a greater or smaller number of primary races, each of which has expanded from an aboriginal nucleus or centre. Thus I conceive that there were several centres for the American group of races, of which the highest in the scale are the Toltecan nations, the lowest the Fuegians. Nor does this view conflict with the general principle, that all these nations and tribes have had, as I have elsewhere expressed it, a common origin; inasmuch as by this term is only meant an indigenous relation to the country they inhabit, and that collective identity of physical traits, mental and moral endowments, language, &c., which characterizes all the American races. The same remarks are applicable to all the other human races; but in the present infnat state of Ethnographic science, the designation of these centres is a task of equal delicacy and difficulty. I may here observe, that whenever I have ventured an opion on this question, it has been in favor of the doctrine of primitive diversities among men, ---an original adaptation of the several races to those varied circumstances of climate and locality, which, while congenial to the one are destructive to the other; and subsequent investigations have confirmed me in these views. See Crania Americana, p. 3; Crania Egyptiaca, p. 37; Distinctive Characteristics of the Aboriginal Race of America, p. 36; Silliman’s American Journal of Science and the Arts, 1847; and my letter to J. R. Bartlett, Esq., in Vol. 2 of the Transactions of the Ethnological Society of New York.

*[**] From the Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia for September and October, 1849.

[Updated September 28, 2019]


Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Gould and Morton: revisionism again... but for what purpose?


Just a note to say that I am aware of the recent PLoS article "The Mismeasure of Science: Stephen Jay Gould versus Samuel George Morton on Skulls and Bias." by Lewis, DeGusta, et al. concerning Gould's analysis of Morton's work.  I'll post a review of the article in the next couple of days as I am just reading it and rereading some of the related citations.

I'll go out on a limb, though, and say that the New York Times article was typical of the sensationalist items that the Science Times often prints.  Nor is it really correct to lump Gould into those who do "social studies of science" as they seem to be as much the target of this as Gould.  Strangely, the article seems to do exactly the opposite of what it claims... instead of showing that scientific methodology can shield knowledge from bias, it actually shows that both the work of both Morton and Gould could be influenced by their "unscientific" concerns, which Gould would have no doubt agreed with.


[Updated September 28, 2019]

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Race & Races in Asa Gray's System of Classification for Elementary Botany (1887)

Asa Gray's discussion of classification in his 1887 primer was another of the many topics and tangential lines of study that could not be included in Until Darwin.  His classification is of interest for a number of reasons, besides simply being one of those examples of "wretched knowledge" that Neuberger devoted his scholarly life to investigating.   In terms of the discussion in Until Darwin, Gray's description of race in the context of describing varieties of species is of particular interest:

From Gray's Lessons in Botany, revised (1887)
RACES are such strongly marked varieties, capable of coming true to seed.  The different sorts of Wheat, Maize, Peas, Radishes, et., are familiar examples.  By selecting those individuals of a species which have developed or inherited any desirable peculiarity, keeping them from mingling with their less promising brethren, and selecting again the most promising plants raised from their seeds, the cultivator may in a few generations render almost any variety transmissible by seed, so long as it is cared for and kept apart.  In fact, this is the way the cultivated domesticated races, so useful to man, have been fixed and preserved.  Races, in fact, can hardly, if at all, be said to exist independently of man.  But man does not produce them.  Such peculiarities --- often surprising enough --- now and then originate, we know not how (the plant sports, as the gardeners say;  they are only preserved, propagated, and generally further developed by the cultivator's skillful care (176).

The idea is that botanical races need to be constantly maintained and that varieties are highly unstable despite their being so "strongly marked." Their distinctions have to be cultivated and "preserved, propagated, and generally further developed." Gray evidences some of the tensions of the years immediately following Darwin's demolishing of the polygenic theory in his answer to the Species Question. The anxiety of the cultivator constantly preserving and propagating, maintaining the distance between those with desirable peculiarities and the "less promising" (176).

In the chapter on Classification and Nomenclature, Gray sets out the stakes in understanding the botanical world.  There is a difference between classification and nomenclature.  They can in many ways stand apart from each other and address fundamentally different approaches to understanding the natural world.  This separation had become not only burdensome, but now in the era after Darwin, could no longer be theoretically maintained if indeed the separation between them was ever stable.

"The vast multiplicity of plants and the various degrees of their relationship imperatively require order and system, not only as to names for designating the kinds of plants, but also as to terms for defining their differences" (175).  At the same time that one must pay close attention to the relations between plants, the naturalist/botanist must also acknowledge that "[s]ome system of nomenclature, or naming, is necessary for fixing and expressing botanical knowledge so as to make it available" (175).  Language makes botanical knowledge available generally and not solely to the person who knows it through experience and observation alone.  It fixes it and allows it to be expressed.  But to be expressed, not only is language necessary, but so too is the ability to determine the differences between plants that are expressed in their names.  What is needed are not names but "terms for defining their differences.  Nomenclature is  concerned with the names of plants.  Terminology supplies names of organs or parts, and terms to designate their differences" which disclose their "kinds and relationships" (175).

Gray gives us the scheme of kinds and relationship which is grounded in the fundamental aspects of life itself. and with "individual beings" who are distinguished from the inorganic not only by organic processes and reproduction, but also because they occur as individuals and not as "masses, which are divisible":
From Gray's Lessons in Botany, revised (1887))
520. Plants and animals have two great particularities: 1st they form themselves; and 2d they multiply themselves.  They reproduce their kind in a continued succession of 
521. Individuals. Mineral things occur in masses, which are divisible into smaller and smaller ones without alteration of properties.  But organic things (vegetables and animals) exist as individual beings.  Each owes its existence to a parent, and produces similar individuals  in its turn."

Perhaps holding on to that notion of a Great Chain of Being, within the context of Darwinism, Gray then states that
each individual is a link of a chain; and to this chain the natural historian applies the name of 
522. Species. All descendants from the same stock therefore compose one species.  And it was from our observing that the several sorts of plants or animals steady reproduce themselves, or in other words, keep up a succession of similar individuals, that the idea of species originated.... observation having familiarized us with the general fact that individuals proceeding from the same stock are essentially alike, we infer from their close resemblance that these similar individuals belong to the same species.  That is we infer it when the individuals are as much like each other as those are which we know, or confidently suppose, to have sprung from the same stock (175).

Notice how different the explanation would be now when we do not have to depend on the observation of surface characteristics, which has often, as in the case of polygenism, led to disastrous errors and the need to repress those knowledges.  But Gray knew that of course "[n]o two individuals are exactly alike; a tendency to variation pervades all living things.  In cultivation, where variations are looked after and cared for, very striking differences come to light, and if in wild nature they are less common or less conspicuous, it is partly because they are uncared for" (175).


In wild nature, because difference is not cared for and cultivated, it is at the least inconspicuous or even selected against (by implication).  But under cultivation --- which carries with it the meanings of culture, training disciplining, regulation, and civilizing --- we find "striking differences" which because they are maintained by the cultivator
From Gray's Lessons in Botany, revised (1887)

When such variant forms are pretty well marked they are called  
524. Varieties....The question often arises, and it is often hard to answer, whether the differences in a particular case is that of variety, or is specific [i.e., it a variety or a species].  If the former, it may be commonly be proved by finding such intermediate degrees of difference in various individuals as to show that no clear distinction can be drawn between them; or else by observing the variety to vary back again in some of its offspring.... For the fundamental law in organic nature is that offspring shall be like parent (175-176).

It is at this point that Gray inserts his discussion of Races.  Significantly, it is listed not with its own section, but under the section on Varieties.  It is one of four types of varieties, though it gets the most involved discussion, most of which is quoted above.  Preserved by the care of human cultivation, races are one manifestation of variety.  The others  are, quoted in their entirety
Bud Varieties are those which spring from buds instead of seed.  They are uncommon to any marked extent.  They are sometimes called Sports, but this name is equally applied to variations among seedlings.
Cross-breeds, strictly so-called, are variations which come from cross-fertilizing one variety of a species with another.
Hybrids are the varieties, if they may be called, which come from the crossing of species.  Only nearly related species can be hybridized; and the resulting progeny is usually self-sterile, but not always.  Hybrid plants, however, may often be fertilized and made prolific by the pollen of one or the other parent.  This produces another kind of cross-breeds (176).
From Blumenbach, Dissertation on Human Varieties
So species are difficult to distinguish from varieties, and varieties are difficult to distinguish from varieties and even within varieties, there is variety, e.g., the case of cross-breeds. Thus:
From Gray's Lessons in Botany, revised (1887))
525. Species are the units in classification.  Varieties, although of utmost importance in cultivation and of considerable consequence in the flora of any country, are of less botanical significance.  For they are apt to be indefinite and to shade off one form into another.  But species, the botanist expects  to be distinct.  Indeed, the practical difference to the botanist between species and varieties is the definite limitation of the one and the indefiniteness of the other.  The botanist determination is partly a matter of observation partly of judgment.  In an enlarged view, varieties may be incipient species; and nearly related species probably came from a common stock in earlier times (176-177). 

But there is one more difference, and it is that the botanical world can, just as the animal, be divided into Order, Cass, Genus, Species, Variety, it can not be arranged in the same way, neither in terms of value (except as an economic value of a cultivated species, which is not intrinsic to the plant, but to the cultivator), nor in terms of a hierarchy or levels of increasing superiority.  Rather than hierarchies in a ladder of being, the botanical world is for Gray self-organized and grouped into "clusters or constellations" of species (177).

As we survey them, they do not form a single and connected chain, stretching from the lowest to the highest organized species, although there obviously are lower and higher grades.  But the species throughout group themselves, as it were, into clusters or constellations, and these into still more comprehensive clusters, and so on, with gaps between.  It is this clustering which is the ground of the recognition of kinds of species, that is, of groups of species of successive grades or degree of generality; such as that of similar species into Genera, or genera into Families or Orders, or orders into Classes.
Having started out with a nod to the Great Chain of Being, Gray, transforms it into clusters that may not be connected to other clusters, or which may be only subparts of larger clusters within which their differences become unimportant.  The sequence of classification:
     KINGDOM
     SERIES (Phanerogamous or Cryptogamous)
     CLASS, Subclass, Cohort
     ORDER or Family, Suborder, Tribe, Subtribe
     GENUS, Subgenus or Section
     SPECIES, Variety
is a description of degrees of difference as much as a description of continuity.  We know this, but Gray is thinking about such things on what is for him a more profound level: 
552. So, although the classes, orders, genera, etc. are natural, or as natural as the systematist can make them, their grouping or order of arrangement in a book, must necessarily be in great measure artificial.  Indeed, it is quite impossible to arrange the orders, or even the few classes, in a single series, and yet have each group stand next to its nearest relatives on both sides. 
553.  Especially it should be understood that, although phanerogamous plants are of a higher grade than cryptogamous, and and angiospermous or ordinary phanerogamous higher than the gymnospermous, yet there is no culmination in the vegetable kingdom, nor any highest or lowest order of phanerogamous plants (182-183).
Like Charles Lyell in his Notebooks on the Species Question (1853-1861), Gray wrestled with the problem of reconciling Darwinian science with design or "the plan according to which the vegetable creation was called into being, with all its grades and diversities among the species, as well of past as of the present time" (182).

The "One Mind" that he invokes comes in as much as a preserver of a natural order as it does in a religious sense.
There are, at nearly the lowest computation, as many as one hundred thousand species of phanerogamous plants, and the cryptogamous species are thought to be still more numerous.  They are all connected by resemblances or relationships, realizations in nature, as we may affirm, of the conception of One Mind (177).
But at its core, the increasing "indefiniteness" as one moves from Genus to Species and to Varieties, gives little support for an conception of a plan of One Mind or a universal Cultivator who orders the world, though, as Sextus Empiricus pointed out, some attempt to explain the indefiniteness of the world by arguing that the Gods or God allow for error and flux so that we might know that there is a plan, because otherwise we would not be able to see the patterns if there was not something against which they might stand out.  Sextus Empiricus does a fine job of demolishing this argument, of course.

After a section pointing out the need for a systematic process of assigning names, though one that preserves some of the traditional nomenclature, Gray goes into the question of systemic classification. The discussion is of interest for its explanation of the Natural System of classification as opposed to the Artificial System of Linneaus that was based more on names than terms.

The distinction between the Artificial System of first Tournefort "founded mainly on the leaves of the flower, the calyx and corolla" and later Linnaeus' system "founded on the stamens and pistils.... Useful as this system was down to a time within the memory of still surviving botanists, it is now completely obsolete" (182).

Now, Gray writes, the Natural System had triumph, though it still could not completely express the plan that he still felt was there underneath the variety of nature.  There are many natural systems, but only one real Natural System of that "one Mind" he and others desperately sought to preserve in the face of the overwhelming evidence of their own studies.
550. Natural System.  A genuine system of botany consists of the orders or families duly arranged under their classes, and having the tribes, the genera, and the species arranged in them according to their relationships.  This, when properly carried out, is the Natural System; because it is intended to express, as well as possible, the various degrees of relationship between plants, as presented in nature; that is, to rank those species and those genera, etc., next to each other in the classification which are really most alike in all respects, or, in other words, which are constructed most nearly on the same particular plan.
551. There can be only one natural system of botany if by this term is meant the plan according to which the vegetable creation was called into being, with all its grades and diversities among the species, as well of past as of the present time.  But there may be many natural systems, if we mean the attempts of men to interpret and express that plan, --- systems which will vary with advancing knowledge, and with the judgment and skill of individual botanists.  These must all be very imperfect, bear the impress of individual minds, and be shaped by the current philosophy of the age.  But the endeavor always is to make the classification answer to Nature, as far as any system can which has to be expressed in a definite an serial arrangement (182).
"Fig. 80.  An American Elm, with Spruce-trees, and on the left Abor Vitae." (Gray's caption)


Perhaps Gray's views owe something to the American Elm.  Note the church steeple in the background to the left of the tree (right click for a full size view).  The context of the illustration is:  "...wherever axillary buds take the lead, there is, of course, no single main stem, continued year after year in a direct line, but the trunk is soon lost in the branches.  Trees so commonly formed have rounded or spreading tops.  Of tress with deliquescent stems, --- that is, with the trunk dissolved, as it were, into the successively divided branches, --- the common American Elm (Fig. 80) is a good illustration."

 [Updated September 28, 2019; May 2021; November 2022]

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Maria Martin Bachman's sketches and paintings for Audubon: On-line Exhibition from the Charleston County Public Library

[May 2021 update:  The online exhibit has been taken down, but is still viable via the Internet Archive's Way back Machine: 
The surviving works by Maria Martin are to be found under arranged under the headings:

Fire Damaged Paintings: Gallery 1, Gallery 2, and Gallery 3.

http://www.pressomatic.com/ccpl/upload/435A.JPG


Sketchbook Paintings: Gallery 1, Gallery 2.

http://www.pressomatic.com/ccpl/upload/MMSB8C.JPG


Sketchbook Paintings: Unidentified Insects

http://www.pressomatic.com/ccpl/upload/MMSB43C.JPG


Birds of America Paintings
These are well worth the time spent in viewing them. Below is one of the paintings from Audubon that that was in part painted by Maria Martin. Fittingly, it is of Bachman's Warbler, named by Audubon for her husband or perhaps for her as well.



Bachman's Warbler (Vermivora bachmanii)
The rare bush Maria Martin drew, Franklinia (Franklinia alatamaha) was named in honor of Benjamin Franklin.  Bachman's Warbler was one of several species of animals named by Audubon in honor of John Bachman.  Sadly, due to the advance of industrial forest management, Bachman's Warbler is thought to be extinct.  According to the National Audubon Society:

Since Western science discovered it in 1832, the Bachman's Warbler has been elusive for ornithologists and birdwatchers. Given that the last individual was confirmed alive in 1961, the Bachman's Warbler is probably extinct. A bright yellow-headed songbird with a black crown and throat patch, this insectivore preferred nesting in shrubs in bottomland hardwood forests and wintered in Cuba – a combination that rendered it extremely vulnerable to habitat destruction.
All of the Audubon painting that Maria Martin contributed to are here via the Charleston County Public Library and from it there is this the painting of the similarly named Bachman's Sparrow (Aimophila aestivalis) to which Maria Martin Bachman also contributed:



[Updated May 16, 2016; September 28, 2019]

Related posts:
Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History

A Short Biography of John Bachman (1790-1874)

Podcast - Charleston's Women Naturalists: Jennifer Scheetz, Archivist, Charleston Museum  
The "American School": A brief timeline of the Monogenist/Polygenist Debate.

Notes on Royal Society’s “Types of Mankind” post
Review of America’s Other Audubon (Brain Pickings Blog)



 

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

A brief additional note to Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History

A brief additional note to "Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History" - Anna and Susanna Lister.

Nature has just put online a slide show highlighting some earlier contributions of women to Natural History:
“300 year old Engravings Shed Light on Women in Science”  The slide show focuses on the work of the sisters Anna and Susanna Lister, whose drawings and copper plate engravings for their father, Martin Lister's Historiae Conchyliorum (1685-1692). [The Slideshow is no longer available via Nature.  See the link to Anne Marie Roos for a view. Sept. 22, 2019] 

Historian Anne Marie Roos stumbled upon them while researching a biography of Lister for Oxford's Cultures of Knowledge project.  They are just wonderful illustrations and again do much to illuminate the contributions of women to Natural History before science became the domain of disciplined scientists and exclusive science societies.

When the English naturalist and physician Martin Lister wrote home from France to his wife Hannah in 1681, he explained that he was enclosing a box of oil colours for his oldest two daughters, 11-year-old Susanna and 9-year-old Anna Lister, to paint with. He also asked her to lock away the precious pencils he was sending, "for they know not yet the use of them."
But within a few years, Lister was relying on the teenage Susanna and Anna to illustrate his landmark compendium of all known shells, the Historiae Conchyliorum, which was assembled between 1685 and 1692, and which was later cited by Charles Darwin. Lister was vice-president of the Royal Society, the United Kingdom's academy of sciences, and his daughters were also pressed into service to illustrate a number of letters published in the society's journal, Philosophical Transactions. Historians now believe the pair were the first women to use microscopes to help produce some of their scientific drawings.
Susanna Lister also illustrated Anthony von Leeuwenhoek’s letter “concerning the appearances of several woods and their vessels as observed in a microscope” (A. Leewenhoeck Philosophical Transactions. 13, 197–208; 1683).



It is a great series of 13 slides and well worth the few minutes to view them.
See as well the article by Jean H. Langenheim "Early History and Progress of Women Ecologists: Emphasis Upon Research Contributions" (Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 1996. 27:1-53) covering the period from c.1860-1975.


Related posts:


Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History
A Short Biography of John Bachman (1790-1874)
Podcast - Charleston's Women Naturalists: Jennifer Scheetz, Archivist, Charleston Museum
The "American School": A brief timeline of the Monogenist/Polygenist Debate.
Notes on Royal Society’s “Types of Mankind” post
Review of America’s Other Audubon (Brain Pickings Blog) 

[Updated November 18, 2017, September 22, 2019; May 2021)

Sunday, December 12, 2010

Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History

There was one of those interesting coincidences in the past weeks that reminded me of a neglected portion of the all too brief essay that is Until Darwin.  The first was the typically fine broadcast of  Melvyn Bragg's In Our Time on Women and Enlightenment Science.  The second was the record breaking auction sale of Audubon's Birds of America (see Audubon's Birds of America: The world's most expensive book and Birds of America sets £7m sales record at Sotheby's). 

Maria Martin's life is one that is well described by Bragg and his guests.  As with most women of the era, advanced formal education was denied her.  On the other hand, science and research at the time was not something done in universities or laboratories, but in the home.  As the managers of the domestic space and through their relationships with their husbands or lovers, women had access to scientific research, often taking the lead but recieving little or no credit.
Charleston, with the steeple of St. John's Church, forms the backdrop
for Audubon's Long-Billed Curlew
 The same can be found in more recent academic works, particularly those of the mid-century before the days of PCs.  The preface for many books will end with a appreciation for the contribution of the spouse to the completion of the work, from the care of the household to "discussions" about the work to its actual editing and typing.

Here is an excerpt from Until Darwin on the connection of Maria Martin and Audubon.  At some point, it would be nice to write something more extensive on this topic.

Before Darwin, the great adversary of polygenism was John Bachman, although he is perhaps best remembered now for his collaboration and friendship with James Audubon. In the Jeffersonian tradition, he too devoted his effort to education, science, and service. Bachman worked tirelessly on a wide range of activities, all the while keeping up a busy ministry. He founded the small liberal arts Newberry College in Newberry, South Carolina. Clearly Natural History held a special importance for Bachman. Teaching at the College of Charleston, he joined the ‘Circle of Naturalists’. Charleston became one of the centers of Natural History, attracting such notables as Agassiz and Audubon. Bachman's association with Audubon began through an almost chance encounter and grew into a life-long friendship, including the marriage of two of Bachman's daughters to Audubon's sons. They spent a great deal of time together collecting along the coastal plain of South Carolina and disputing their divergent ways of life. Bachman often admonished Audubon for his love of ‘gog and wine and snuff’. Maria Martin Bachman, who had married Bachman after the death of her sister --- Bachman's first wife--- found in Audubon's friendship the opportunity to become a notable Natural History painter and illustrator. Many of the backgrounds and detailed vegetation illustrations which put Audubon's birds in context were painted by Maria Martin. Her contributions included the beautifully and accurately detailed entomological drawings that accompany Audubon's birds. This she learned on her on by studying the abundant specimen available to her as well as the drawings in Say's Entomology of North America. Her work with Audubon was common knowledge. One of her descendants noted in Charleston Receipts that ‘It was she who painted many of the backgrounds for Audubon's famous paintings’.97 All this while she gave birth to 14 children, suffered from tic douloureux, a nerve disease that produces a severe stabbing pain on one side of the face and is often triggered by the slightest touch or movement which causes the sufferer to wince involuntarily and can itself sometimes increase the severity of the attack. It is considered one of the most painful chronic conditions in found in humans. Audubon wrote of her that "Miss Martin with her superior talents, assists us greatly in the way of drawing; the insects she has drawn are, perhaps, the best I've seen."98
______
97.  Junior League of Charleston. Recipe for Soused Fish, in Charleston Receipts (Charleston, S.C.: Walker Evans & Cogswell Co., 1950), p. 72. . ‘Receipts’ rather than ‘recipes’, they say, ‘to designate time-honored dishes according to ancestral wishes’.
98.  Letter to Victor Audubon, December 24, 1833, in F. H. Herrick, Audubon the Naturalist: A History of his Life and Times, vol. 2 (New York: Appleton, 1917), p. 62. See also Bonta, M.M., Women in the Field: America's Pioneering Women Naturalists (College Station, TX: Texas A&M University Press, 1991).
And this excerpt as well from my entry on John Bachman in the Dictionary of Early American Philosophers (Thoemmes Continuum, 2010).
The war years were difficult for Bachman. The blockades prevented normal scientific communication and no one could avoid the constant fighting in and around Charleston. In the midst of the war, Bachman published his last major essay, “Characteristics of Genera and Species, as Applicable to the Doctrine of Unity in the Human Race” but Darwin had already brought an end to the polygenic/monogenic dispute. Maria Martin died in 1863, and one of Bachman's sons was mortally wounded fighting for the Confederacy. Now, with Maria dead and Sherman's forces advancing on Charleston, Bachman fully realized his own pre-war warning about “the duties and dangers of the moment.” The new bell of his church was melted down for Confederate ammunition as the city came under attack in the final siege and capture of Charleston that left Bachman's church, school, and library in ruins. With them, much of Bachman's papers and collections, as well as Maria's sketches and paintings, were lost. Bachman attempted to flee to Newberry College, but while journeying there his party was detained by Union troopers. During the encounter, he was badly beaten and left with a paralyzed arm.
With the end of the Civil War, Bachman concentrated his efforts on his role as pastor of St. John's, retiring in 1871. Bachman had signed his essay to war profiteers as “Marcus Curtius,” the Roman hero who rode his horse into the abyss to save Rome from the chasm that had opened in the Forum. An alter was raised over the spot and it is appropriate that John Bachman, who was often called the “Old Roman” by his friends, was himself buried under the alter of his church. In his life and work, he personified many of the contradictions of his educated and religious contemporaries who promoted both social reform and the preservation of archaic institutions.
Of course, we must end by noting that according to the 1860 Charleston Census of Slaves, John and Maria Martin Bachman owned five humans, with John possessing one and Maria Martin listed as owning four.  Because science was a domestic enterprise during the Enlightenment --- and therefore women were provided access to scientific studies despite being barred from formal education --- the administration of slaves in the household would coincide with the production and care of scientific instruments and specimens, the upkeep of gardens, the organization of observations, the parlor meetings of Natural History societies, and all other activities that took place within the domestic space.  Scarlett O'Hara was not only a fictional proto-mainstream feminist, but also the manager/overseer of the large number of slaves working in the productive domestic/industrial space of the plantation house and grounds.

The stain of slavery permeates the 19th Century - from the cotton supplying the Engels family' textile mill to the nightmares of Brazilian slavery that Darwin regularly suffered at Down House to the streets of Charleston, where freedmen and slaves wore badges identifying their occupation and the slaver.  It's effects are to be found wherever one looks, and can be found on the pages of Maria Bachman's drawings, which retain a certain aura of authenticity as having been held by her, but they were also no doubt held by the hands of slaves just as certainly as they bear the stains of the Civil War and the destruction of John and Maria Bachman's library, church, and schools.

Here are some of the few works by Maria Martin Bachman that survived the destruction of Charleston and its aftermath. 



The contribution of "Mrs. Gliddon" to Types of Mankind in a later post.

See also:
A Short Biography of John Bachman (1790-1874)
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2011/07/short-biography-of-john-bachman-1790.html
 

Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2010/12/audubons-birds-and-some-often.html

A brief additional note to Audubon's Birds and some often Overlooked Contributions of Women to Natural History
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2010/12/brief-additional-note-to-audubons-birds.html

Maria Martin Bachman's sketches and paintings for Audubon: On-line Exhibition from the Charleston County Public Library
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2011/02/maria-martin-bachmans-sketches-and.html

Review of America’s Other Audubon (Brain Pickings Blog)
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2012/07/review-of-americas-other-audubon-brain.html

Podcast - Charleston's Women Naturalists: Jennifer Scheetz, Archivist, Charleston Museum
http://until-darwin.blogspot.com/2012/04/podcast-charlestons-women-naturalists.html


(Updated November 18, 2017; September 21, 2019; June 2021)